Remember those frustrating moments when you struggle to open a can of tomatoes or beans? 🤔 Well, you're not alone! In today's kitchen landscape, having a reliable can opener is more important than ever, even if we don't rely on canned foods as much as families did in the past. After rigorous testing of 12 different models and opening over 100 cans of various shapes and sizes, the results are in—and they might surprise you!

the-ultimate-guide-to-choosing-the-best-can-opener-in-2025-top-picks-and-expert-testing-image-0:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/sea-primary-tier-3-best-can-openers-nsimpson-78-c41ea415fbc249aa9c1d6751ec4e410f.jpeg)

The Top Performers Revealed

OXO Good Grips Soft Handle Manual Can Opener - The Champion

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/oxo-good-grip-soft-handle-manual-can-opener-f9ebb970ae264caab3faec6de8182f19.jpg)

What makes it special:

  • Soft, grippy handles that are nonslip even when wet

  • Large, comfortable knob that turns easily

  • Opens cans faster than any other model tested

  • Tight hinge that opens wide for easy cleaning

  • Creates relatively smooth edges with minimal jagged areas

The testing revealed that each rotation of the OXO's knob rotated the can farther than other models, making it significantly speedier. The comfortable grip reduces hand fatigue, making it perfect for those who regularly use canned ingredients.

Bartelli Safety Can Opener - The Safe Choice

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/bartelli-soft-edge-3-in-1-ambidextrous-safety-can-jar-bottle-opener-14f4bfe5d1cc4a29894668f1301be181.jpg)

Why it stands out:

  • Safety design creates smooth edges instead of sharp ones

  • Ambidextrous operation (works for both left and right-handed users)

  • No need to tightly clamp like traditional openers

  • Perfect for people with arthritis or limited mobility

  • Compact design for easy storage

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/Serious-Eats-Bartelli-In-Use-Can-Openers-Irvin-Lin-2281-61288e521e734ae1a9cd43ce85c99cfb.jpg)

Beneno Manual Can Opener - The Feature-Packed Option

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/beneno-can-opener-dd293be9f9744867bc6903f3aefcfbb6.jpg)

Key features:

  • Magnetic attachment for easy lid removal

  • Wide-opening hinges for thorough cleaning

  • Comfortable soft grip handles

  • Functions similarly to the OXO but with magnetic convenience

🔬 The Testing Process: Beyond Simple Opening

The comprehensive testing involved multiple stages to ensure each can opener could handle real-world kitchen challenges:

Standard Can Test

  • Three 14.5-ounce cans (chickpeas, corn, diced tomatoes)

  • One 14-ounce can of sweetened condensed milk

  • Evaluation of smoothness, speed, and ease of use

Specialized Testing Categories

Test Type Can Sizes Tested Purpose
Small Can 5-6 ounce cans Handling petite containers
Large Can 28-ounce tomatoes Managing substantial sizes
Odd Shapes Oval sardine cans Versatility assessment
Cleaning Multiple washes Maintenance evaluation

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/Serious-Eats-Group-Can-Openers-Irvin-Lin-2251-2baa15252a93443081bcdc4819ae5478.jpg)

💡 Key Findings: What Really Matters in a Can Opener

Handle and Knob Design is Crucial

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/Serious-Eats-Oxo-Can-Openers-Irvin-Lin-2169-8296b52bbd454014b1f4f6ca8189cb31.jpg)

The testing revealed that larger, softer handles and knobs significantly improved the user experience. Models with hard plastic or thin metal handles caused fatigue during extended use. But did you know that bigger knobs can sometimes be problematic with shallow cans? 🤔

Hinge Mechanism Matters More Than You Think

  • Tight hinges prevent unexpected swinging

  • Wide-opening hinges make cleaning much easier

  • Loose hinges can be frustrating and less stable

Safety vs. Traditional: Which is Better?

:max_bytes(150000):strip_icc():format(webp)/Serious-Eats-Lid-Comparison-Jagged-Edge-Can-Openers-Irvin-Lin-2289-97d664ea3323401085e887046e94d813.jpg)

Traditional rotary openers create potentially dangerous jagged edges, while safety openers like the Bartelli produce smooth, safe edges. The choice depends on your priorities: speed versus safety.

🚫 Models to Avoid: The Testing Failures

Several models underperformed significantly during testing:

❌ Fixed can openers created dangerously sharp edges

❌ Cheap models like the Farberware Pro 2 performed poorly

❌ Several options rusted quickly after washing

❌ Some had difficulty opening oval or unusual-shaped cans

Maintenance Tips for Longevity

Proper care can extend your can opener's life significantly:

  • Hand wash only - avoid dishwashers

  • Dry thoroughly before storage to prevent rust

  • Clean immediately after use for easy maintenance

  • Regular inspection for rust or damage

🤔 Which One Should You Choose?

For Most People: OXO Good Grips

  • Best overall performance

  • Fastest opening speed

  • Excellent comfort and grip

For Safety-Conscious Users: Bartelli

  • Smooth, safe edges

  • Ambidextrous design

  • Great for those with mobility issues

For Feature Lovers: Beneno

  • Magnetic lid removal

  • Good overall performance

  • Easy cleaning design

🌟 The Verdict

After opening over 100 cans and extensive testing, the OXO Good Grips emerges as the clear winner for its combination of speed, comfort, and reliability. However, the Bartelli safety opener offers unique advantages for specific needs. Remember, a good can opener should make kitchen tasks easier, not harder!

What's your experience with can openers? Have you found the perfect one for your kitchen?